Quantum trajectories and Cushing's historical contingency

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that classical wave phenomena and quantum particle dynamics can be described using a Hamiltonian framework with a Wave Potential, revealing a deep connection between classical and quantum mechanics without statistical assumptions.

Contribution

It extends classical Hamiltonian optics concepts to quantum mechanics, showing that Bohm's Quantum Potential is a wave property and establishing an exact trajectory-based quantum dynamics framework.

Findings

Classical wave beams are governed by a dispersive Wave Potential in the Helmholtz equation.

Quantum particle trajectories are coupled by a function analogous to the Wave Potential, similar to Bohm's Quantum Potential.

The Schrödinger equation's time-independent form underpins the exact quantum dynamics, linking classical and quantum descriptions.

Abstract

With an apparent delay of over one century with respect to the development of standard Analytical Mechanics, but still in fully classical terms, the behavior of classical monochromatic wave beams in stationary media is shown to be ruled by a dispersive "Wave Potential" function, encoded in the structure of the Helmholtz equation. An exact, ray-based Hamiltonian description, revealing a strong ray coupling due to the Wave Potential, and reducing to the geometrical optics approximation when this function is neglected, is shown to hold even for typically wave-like phenomena such as diffraction and interference. Recalling, then, that the time-independent Schroedinger equation (associating the quantum motion of mono-energetic particles with stationary monochromatic matter waves) is itself a Helmholtz-like equation, the mathematical treatment holding in the classical case is extended, without resorting to statistical concepts, to the exact, trajectory-based, Hamiltonian quantum dynamics of point-like particles. The particle trajectories and motion laws turn out to be coupled, in this case, by a function strictly analogous to the Wave Potential and formally assuming the familiar form of Bohm's "Quantum Potential", which is therefore not so much a "quantum" as a "wave" property - in whose absence the quantum particle dynamics reduces to the classical one. The time-independent Schroedinger equation is argued to be not a trivial particular case of the time-dependent one, but the exact quantum dynamical ground on which Schroedinger's time-dependent statistical description (representing particles as travelling wave-packets) is based. It provides indeed the (exact) link between classical particle dynamics and Bohm's hydrodynamics.