Cosmological Evolution of Supermassive Black Holes. II. Evidence for Downsizing of Spin Evolution

TL;DR

This study investigates the evolution of supermassive black hole spins over cosmic time, revealing a mass-dependent pattern where high-mass black holes spin down at low redshifts, supporting a downsizing scenario in SMBH growth.

Contribution

It provides the first explicit mass-dependent model of SMBH spin evolution using the continuity equation and observational data, highlighting a transition from spin-up to spin-down phases.

Findings

Radiative efficiency increases with mass at high redshift

Efficiency drops significantly for high-mass black holes by z~0

Transition from prolonged to episodic accretion occurs around z~2 for massive SMBHs

Abstract

The spin is an important but poorly constrained parameter for describing supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Using the continuity equation of SMBH number density, we explicitly obtain the mass-dependent cosmological evolution of the radiative efficiency for accretion, which serves as a proxy for SMBH spin. Our calculations make use of the SMBH mass function of active and inactive galaxies (derived in the first paper of this series), the bolometric luminosity function of active galactic nuclei (AGNs), corrected for the contribution from Compton-thick sources, and the observed Eddington ratio distribution. We find that the radiative efficiency generally increases with increasing black hole mass at high redshifts (z>~1), roughly as \eta \propto M_bh^0.5, while the trend reverses at lower redshifts, such that the highest efficiencies are attained by the lowest mass black holes. Black holes with M_bh>~10^8.5M_sun maintain radiative efficiencies as high as \eta~0.3-0.4 at high redshifts, near the maximum for rapidly spinning systems, but their efficiencies drop dramatically (by an order of magnitude) by z~0. The pattern for lower mass holes is somewhat more complicated but qualitatively similar. Assuming that the standard accretion disk model applies, we suggest that the accretion history of SMBHs and their accompanying spins evolve in two distinct regimes: an early phase of prolonged accretion, plausibly driven by major mergers, during which the black hole spins up, then switching to a period of random, episodic accretion, governed by minor mergers and internal secular processes, during which the hole spins down. The transition epoch depends on mass, mirroring other evidence for "cosmic downsizing" in the AGN population; it occurs at z~2 for high-mass black holes, and somewhat later, at z~1, for lower-mass systems.