Thermodynamic analysis of the Quantum Critical behavior of Ce-lattice compounds

TL;DR

This paper systematically analyzes the thermodynamic conditions of Ce-lattice compounds to identify those capable of exhibiting quantum critical behavior, based on specific heat and entropy measurements, and classifies their phase diagrams.

Contribution

It introduces a classification of low temperature phase diagrams of Ce compounds and identifies thermodynamic criteria for quantum criticality.

Findings

Only systems with entropy vanishing as temperature approaches zero are candidates for quantum critical behavior.

Magnetic phase boundaries deviate from classical behavior below 2.5 K, indicating potential quantum criticality.

A pre-critical region with modified magnetic transition nature is identified in Ce-ligand alloys.

Abstract

A systematic analysis of low temperature magnetic phase diagrams of Ce compounds is performed in order to recognize the thermodynamic conditions to be fulfilled by those systems to reach a quantum critical regime and, alternatively, to identify other kinds of low temperature behaviors. Based on specific heat ($C_m$) and entropy ($S_m$) results, three different types of phase diagrams are recognized: i) with the entropy involved into the ordered phase ($S_{MO}$) decreasing proportionally to the ordering temperature ($T_{MO}$), ii) those showing a transference of degrees of freedom from the ordered phase to a non-magnetic component, with their $C_m(T_{MO})$ jump ($\Delta C_m$) vanishing at finite temperature, and iii) those ending in a critical point at finite temperature because their $\Delta C_m$ do not decrease with $T_{MO}$ producing an entropy accumulation at low temperature. Only those systems belonging to the first case, i.e. with $S_{MO}\to 0$ as $T_{MO}\to 0$, can be regarded as candidates for quantum critical behavior. Their magnetic phase boundaries deviate from the classical negative curvature below $T\approx 2.5$\,K, denouncing frequent misleading extrapolations down to T=0. Different characteristic concentrations are recognized and analyzed for Ce-ligand alloyed systems. Particularly, a pre-critical region is identified, where the nature of the magnetic transition undergoes significant modifications, with its $\partial C_m/\partial T$ discontinuity strongly affected by magnetic field and showing an increasing remnant entropy at $T\to 0$. Physical constraints arising from the third law at $T\to 0$ are discussed and recognized from experimental results.