Understanding agent-based models of financial markets: a bottom-up approach based on order parameters and phase diagrams

TL;DR

This paper introduces a bottom-up framework using order parameters and phase diagrams to analyze agent-based models of financial markets, illustrating how different trader behaviors influence market phases.

Contribution

It presents a novel approach to understanding agent-based financial models through phase diagrams derived from order parameters, bridging deterministic and stochastic models.

Findings

Identified three market phases: dead, boom, and jammed.

Stochasticity eliminates the dead market phase.

Order parameters from steady-state distributions effectively characterize market states.

Abstract

We describe a bottom-up framework, based on the identification of appropriate order parameters and determination of phase diagrams, for understanding progressively refined agent-based models and simulations of financial markets. We illustrate this framework by starting with a deterministic toy model, whereby $N$ independent traders buy and sell $M$ stocks through an order book that acts as a clearing house. The price of a stock increases whenever it is bought and decreases whenever it is sold. Price changes are updated by the order book before the next transaction takes place. In this deterministic model, all traders based their buy decisions on a call utility function, and all their sell decisions on a put utility function. We then make the agent-based model more realistic, by either having a fraction $f_b$ of traders buy a random stock on offer, or a fraction $f_s$ of traders sell a random stock in their portfolio. Based on our simulations, we find that it is possible to identify useful order parameters from the steady-state price distributions of all three models. Using these order parameters as a guide, we find three phases: (i) the dead market; (ii) the boom market; and (iii) the jammed market in the the phase diagram of the deterministic model. Comparing the phase diagrams of the stochastic models against that of the deterministic model, we realize that the primary effect of stochasticity is to eliminate the dead market phase.