Constraints on Neutrino Mass and Light Degrees of Freedom in Extended Cosmological Parameter Spaces

TL;DR

This study examines how uncertainties in cosmological parameters affect constraints on neutrino properties, finding mild evidence for extra light species and robust bounds on neutrino mass across extended models.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of neutrino constraints considering extended cosmological parameters, including dark energy evolution and early dark energy.

Findings

Mild (2.2 sigma) preference for additional light degrees of freedom.

Effective number of neutrinos consistent with 3 neutrinos within 1 sigma when allowing for dark energy evolution.

Neutrino mass upper bound of 1.2 eV (95% CL) robust across extended models.

Abstract

From a combination of probes including the cosmic microwave background (WMAP7+SPT), Hubble constant (HST), baryon acoustic oscillations (SDSS+2dFGRS), and supernova distances (Union2), we have explored the extent to which the constraints on the effective number of neutrinos and sum of neutrino masses are affected by our ignorance of other cosmological parameters, including the curvature of the universe, running of the spectral index, primordial helium abundance, evolving late-time dark energy, and early dark energy. In a combined analysis of the effective number of neutrinos and sum of neutrino masses, we find mild (2.2 sigma) preference for additional light degrees of freedom. However, the effective number of neutrinos is consistent with the canonical expectation of 3 massive neutrinos and no extra relativistic species to within 1 sigma when allowing for evolving dark energy and relaxing the strong inflation prior on the curvature and running. The agreement improves with the possibility of an early dark energy component, itself constrained to be less than 5% of the critical density (95% CL) in our expanded parameter space. In extensions of the standard cosmological model, the derived amplitude of linear matter fluctuations sigma_8 is found to closely agree with low-redshift cluster abundance measurements. The sum of neutrino masses is robust to assumptions of the effective number of neutrinos, late-time dark energy, curvature, and running at the level of 1.2 eV (95% CL). The upper bound degrades to 2.0 eV (95% CL) when further including the early dark energy density and primordial helium abundance as additional free parameters. Even in extended cosmological parameter spaces, Planck alone could determine the possible existence of extra relativistic species at 4 sigma confidence and constrain the sum of neutrino masses to 0.2 eV (68% CL).