Impulsive Phase Coronal Hard X-ray Sources in an X3.9 Class Solar Flare

TL;DR

This study analyzes high-energy coronal hard X-ray sources during a powerful solar flare, revealing unexpected spectral properties and emphasizing the importance of imaging spectroscopy for understanding electron acceleration mechanisms.

Contribution

It provides detailed imaging spectroscopy of energetic coronal HXR sources up to 150 keV, challenging existing stochastic acceleration models and suggesting additional electron confinement processes.

Findings

High-energy coronal sources detected up to 150 keV

Spectral index differences smaller than expected from simple models

Correlation between coronal electrons and type III radio bursts

Abstract

[Abridged]We present analysis of a pair of unusually energetic coronal hard X-ray (HXR) sources detected by RHESSI during the impulsive phase of an X3.9 class solar flare on 2003 November 3, which simultaneously shows two intense footpoint (FP) sources. A distinct loop top (LT) coronal source is detected up to ~150 keV and a second (upper) coronal source up to ~80 keV. These photon energies are much higher than commonly observed in coronal sources and pose grave modeling challenges. The LT source in general appears higher in altitude with increasing energy and exhibits a more limited motion compared to the expansion of the thermal loop. The high energy LT source shows an impulsive time profile and its nonthermal power law spectrum exhibits soft-hard-soft evolution during the impulsive phase, similar to the FP sources. The upper coronal source exhibits an opposite spatial gradient and a similar spectral slope compared to the LT source. These properties are consistent with the model of stochastic acceleration of electrons by plasma waves or turbulence. However, the LT and FP spectral index difference (varying from ~0-1) is much smaller than commonly measured and than that expected from a simple stochastic acceleration model. Additional confinement or trapping mechanisms of high energy electrons in the corona are required. Comprehensive modeling including both kinetic effects and the macroscopic flare structure may shed light on this behavior. These results highlight the importance of imaging spectroscopic observations of the LT and FP sources up to high energies in understanding electron acceleration in solar flares. Finally, we show that the electrons producing the upper coronal HXR source may very likely be responsible for the type III radio bursts at the decimetric/metric wavelength observed during the impulsive phase of this flare.