Many-body effects in magnetic inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy

TL;DR

This paper compares one-electron and many-body theories for magnetic inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy, revealing new many-body features like sharp peaks near thresholds that persist at higher temperatures.

Contribution

It introduces a many-body theoretical approach to magnetic IETS, highlighting intrinsic features beyond the one-electron approximation, including persistent peaks at elevated temperatures.

Findings

Many-body features produce sharp peaks near inelastic thresholds.

These features are not localized exactly at thresholds.

They persist at temperatures higher than the Kondo temperature.

Abstract

Magnetic inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) shows sharp increases in conductance when a new conductance channel associated to a change in magnetic structure is open. Typically, the magnetic moment carried by an adsorbate can be changed by collision with a tunneling electron; in this process the spin of the electron can flip or not. A previous one-electron theory [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 103}, 176601 (2009)] successfully explained both the conductance thresholds and the magnitude of the conductance variation. The elastic spin flip of conduction electrons by a magnetic impurity leads to the well known Kondo effect. In the present work, we compare the theoretical predictions for inelastic magnetic tunneling obtained with a one-electron approach and with a many-body theory including Kondo-like phenomena. We apply our theories to a singlet-triplet transition model system that contains most of the characteristics revealed in magnetic IETS. We use two self-consistent treatments (non-crossing approximation and self-consistent ladder approximation). We show that, although the one-electron limit is properly recovered, new intrinsic many-body features appear. In particular, sharp peaks appear close to the inelastic thresholds; these are not localized exactly at thresholds and could influence the determination of magnetic structures from IETS experiments.Analysis of the evolution with temperature reveals that these many-body features involve an energy scale different from that of the usual Kondo peaks. Indeed, the many-body features perdure at temperatures much larger than the one given by the Kondo energy scale of the system.