Thermal Phase Variations of WASP-12b: Defying Predictions

TL;DR

This study presents detailed infrared phase observations of WASP-12b revealing unexpected thermal variations, atmospheric opacity differences, and potential ellipsoidal effects, challenging existing models of hot Jupiter atmospheres.

Contribution

It provides the first full-orbit phase measurements at 3.6 and 4.5 microns, highlighting discrepancies with predictions and proposing new interpretations of observed variations.

Findings

Large amplitude phase variations suggest poor heat redistribution.

Transit depths indicate higher opacity at 3.6 micron than at 4.5 micron.

Detected 4.5 micron ellipsoidal variations are stronger than models predict.

Abstract

[Abridged] We report Warm Spitzer full-orbit phase observations of WASP-12b at 3.6 and 4.5 micron. We are able to measure the transit depths, eclipse depths, thermal and ellipsoidal phase variations at both wavelengths. The large amplitude phase variations, combined with the planet's previously-measured day-side spectral energy distribution, is indicative of non-zero Bond albedo and very poor day-night heat redistribution. The transit depths in the mid-infrared indicate that the atmospheric opacity is greater at 3.6 than at 4.5 micron, in disagreement with model predictions, irrespective of C/O ratio. The secondary eclipse depths are consistent with previous studies. We do not detect ellipsoidal variations at 3.6 micron, but our parameter uncertainties -estimated via prayer-bead Monte Carlo- keep this non-detection consistent with model predictions. At 4.5 micron, on the other hand, we detect ellipsoidal variations that are much stronger than predicted. If interpreted as a geometric effect due to the planet's elongated shape, these variations imply a 3:2 ratio for the planet's longest:shortest axes and a relatively bright day-night terminator. If we instead presume that the 4.5 micron ellipsoidal variations are due to uncorrected systematic noise and we fix the amplitude of the variations to zero, the best fit 4.5 micron transit depth becomes commensurate with the 3.6 micron depth, within the uncertainties. The relative transit depths are then consistent with a Solar composition and short scale height at the terminator. Assuming zero ellipsoidal variations also yields a much deeper 4.5 micron eclipse depth, consistent with a Solar composition and modest temperature inversion. We suggest future observations that could distinguish between these two scenarios.