Constraint on the Low Energy Constants of Wilson Chiral Perturbation Theory

TL;DR

This paper derives a universal constraint on the low energy constant W'_8 in Wilson chiral perturbation theory, impacting the understanding of phase structure and spectrum in lattice QCD with Wilson fermions.

Contribution

It provides an alternative proof that W'_8 is non-positive, refining the theoretical bounds on low energy constants in Wilson chiral perturbation theory.

Findings

W'_8 

W'_8 

2W'_6 > |W'_8| for first-order phase scenario

Abstract

Wilson chiral perturbation theory (WChPT) is the effective field theory describing the long- distance properties of lattice QCD with Wilson or twisted-mass fermions. We consider here WChPT for the theory with two light flavors of Wilson fermions or a single light twisted-mass fermion. Discretization errors introduce three low energy constants (LECs) into partially quenched WChPT at O(a^2), conventionally called W'_6, W'_7 and W'_8 . The phase structure of the theory at non-zero a depends on the sign of the combination 2W'_6 + W'_8, while the spectrum of the lattice Hermitian Wilson-Dirac operator depends on all three constants. It has been argued, based on the positivity of partition functions of fixed topological charge, and on the convergence of graded group integrals that arise in the epsilon-regime of ChPT, that there is a constraint on the LECs arising from the underlying lattice theory. In particular, for W'_6 = W'_7 = 0, the constraint found is W'_8 \le 0. Here we provide an alternative line of argument, based on mass inequalities for the underlying partially quenched theory. We find that W'_8 \le 0, irrespective of the values of W'_6 and W'_7. Our constraint implies that 2W'_6 > |W'_8| if the phase diagram is to be described by the first-order scenario, as recent simulations suggest is the case for some choices of action.