Kinetic theory of Onsager's vortices in two-dimensional hydrodynamics

TL;DR

This paper derives a kinetic equation for 2D point vortex gases from the Liouville equation, revealing how correlations affect relaxation and equilibrium, and discussing the conditions under which vortices reach or do not reach statistical equilibrium.

Contribution

It provides the first correction to the 2D Euler equation accounting for correlations and analyzes the relaxation processes and equilibrium states of vortex distributions.

Findings

Kinetic equation valid at order 1/N including correlations

Axisymmetric distributions do not relax to Boltzmann equilibrium

Non-axisymmetric distributions may relax via resonances

Abstract

Starting from the Liouville equation, and using a BBGKY-like hierarchy, we derive a kinetic equation for the point vortex gas in two-dimensional (2D) hydrodynamics, taking two-body correlations and collective effects into account. This equation is valid at the order 1/N where N>>1 is the number of point vortices in the system (we assume that their individual circulation scales like \gamma ~ 1/N). It gives the first correction, due to graininess and correlation effects, to the 2D Euler equation that is obtained for $N\rightarrow +\infty$. For axisymmetric distributions, this kinetic equation does not relax towards the Boltzmann distribution of statistical equilibrium. This implies either that (i) the "collisional" (correlational) relaxation time is larger than Nt_D, where t_D is the dynamical time, so that three-body, four-body... correlations must be taken into account in the kinetic theory, or (ii) that the point vortex gas is non-ergodic (or does not mix well) and will never attain statistical equilibrium. Non-axisymmetric distributions may relax towards the Boltzmann distribution on a timescale of the order Nt_D due to the existence of additional resonances, but this is hard to prove from the kinetic theory. On the other hand, 2D Euler unstable vortex distributions can experience a process of "collisionless" (correlationless) violent relaxation towards a non-Boltzmannian quasistationary state (QSS) on a very short timescale of the order of a few dynamical times. This QSS is possibly described by the Miller-Robert-Sommeria (MRS) statistical theory which is the counterpart, in the context of two-dimensional hydrodynamics, of the Lynden-Bell statistical theory of violent relaxation in stellar dynamics.