Thermally Pulsing Asymptotic Giant Branch Star Models and Globular Cluster Planetary Nebulae I: The Model

TL;DR

This paper develops synthetic models of thermally pulsing asymptotic giant branch stars to match observed properties of globular cluster planetary nebulae, incorporating new mass-loss calculations and exploring various progenitor scenarios.

Contribution

It introduces new mass-loss prescriptions and models for globular cluster planetary nebulae, including effects of helium enhancement and blue straggler origins, to better match observations.

Findings

Models successfully reproduce chemical compositions and core masses of observed nebulae.

Progenitor stars with helium enhancement explain some planetary nebulae.

Binary scenarios may be necessary to explain certain nebulae like K648.

Abstract

Thermally pulsing asymptotic giant branch models of globular cluster stars are calculated using a synthetic model with the goal of reproducing the chemical composition, core masses and other observational parameters of the four known globular cluster planetary nebulae as well as roughly matching the overall cluster properties. The evolution of stars with an enhanced helium abundance ($Y$) and blue stragglers are modeled. New pre-thermally pulsing asymptotic giant branch mass-losses for red giant branch and early asymptotic giant branch stars are calculated from the Padova stellar evolution models \citep{berta,bertb}. The new mass-losses are calculated to get the relative differences in mass-losses due to enhanced helium abundances. The global properties of the globular cluster planetary nebula are reproduced with these models. The metallicity, mass of the central star, overall metallicities, helium abundance and the nebular mass are matched to the observational values. Globular cluster planetary nebulae JaFu 1 and JaFu 2 are reproduced {\it by assuming progenitor stars} with masses near the typical main sequence turn-offs of globular clusters and with enhanced helium abundances very similar to the enhancements inferred from fitting isochrones to globular cluster colour-magnitude diagrams. The globular cluster PN GJJC-1 can be roughly fit by a progenitor star with very extreme helium enhancement ($Y\approx0.40$) near the turn-off producing a central star with the same mass as inferred by observations and a very low nebular mass. The abundances and core mass of planetary nebula Ps 1 and its central star (K648) are reproduced by a blue straggler model. However, it turned out to be impossible to reproduce its nebular mass and it is concluded some kind of binary scenario may be needed to explain K648.