Graphite and Hexagonal Boron-Nitride Possess the Same Interlayer Distance. Why?

TL;DR

This study explains why graphite and hexagonal boron nitride have nearly identical interlayer distances despite their different atomic properties, by analyzing their interlayer bonding contributions.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed comparative analysis of interlayer bonding in graphite and h-BN, revealing the similar dispersive and electrostatic contributions that lead to identical interlayer distances.

Findings

Interlayer electrostatic monopolar contributions are negligible in h-BN.

Dispersive C6 coefficients are similar in both materials.

Overall interlayer binding energies are nearly identical.

Abstract

Graphite and hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) are two prominent members of the family of layered materials possessing a hexagonal lattice. While graphite has non-polar homo-nuclear C-C intra-layer bonds, h-BN presents highly polar B-N bonds resulting in different optimal stacking modes of the two materials in bulk form. Furthermore, the static polarizabilities of the constituent atoms considerably differ from each other suggesting large differences in the dispersive component of the interlayer bonding. Despite these major differences both materials present practically identical interlayer distances. To understand this finding, a comparative study of the nature of the interlayer bonding in both materials is presented. A full lattice sum of the interactions between the partially charged atomic centers in h-BN results in vanishingly small monopolar electrostatic contributions to the interlayer binding energy. Higher order electrostatic multipoles, exchange, and short-range correlation contributions are found to be very similar in both materials and to almost completely cancel out by the Pauli repulsions at physically relevant interlayer distances resulting in a marginal effective contribution to the interlayer binding. Further analysis of the dispersive energy term reveals that despite the large differences in the individual atomic polarizabilities the hetero-atomic B-N C6 coefficient is very similar to the homo-atomic C-C coefficient in the hexagonal bulk form resulting in very similar dispersive contribution to the interlayer binding. The overall binding energy curves of both materials are thus very similar predicting practically the same interlayer distance and very similar binding energies.