Elementary excitations and the phase transition in the bimodal Ising spin glass model

TL;DR

This paper investigates the phase transition in the 2D bimodal Ising spin glass model by analyzing elementary excitations, revealing finite size effects and estimating the critical defect concentration for the transition.

Contribution

It provides a novel understanding of the phase transition through elementary excitations and clarifies the finite size effects influencing the energy gap.

Findings

Finite size effects cause a 2J gap in small systems.

Absence of 2J excitations characterizes the ferromagnetic phase.

Estimated critical defect concentration p_c = 0.1045(11).

Abstract

We show how the nature of the the phase transition in the two-dimensional bimodal Ising spin glass model can be understood in terms of elementary excitations. Although the energy gap with the ground state is expected to be 4J in the ferromagnetic phase, a gap 2J is in fact found if the finite lattice is wound around a cylinder of odd circumference $L$. This 2J gap is really a finite size effect that should not occur in the thermodynamic limit of the ferromagnet. The spatial influence of the frustration must be limited and not wrap around the system if $L$ is large enough. In essence, the absence of 2J excitations defines the ferromagnetic phase without recourse to calculating magnetisation or investigating the system response to domain wall defects. This study directly investigates the response to temperature. We also estimate the defect concentration where the phase transition to the spin glass glass state occurs. The value $p_c = 0.1045(11)$ is in reasonable agreement with the literature.