What are Published X-ray lightcurves telling us about Young Supernova Expansion?

TL;DR

This study analyzes X-ray lightcurves of young supernovae to determine the nature of their surrounding medium, revealing that many do not expand into steady winds as traditionally assumed, especially among Type IIn supernovae.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of X-ray lightcurves across all known SNe, challenging the common assumption of steady wind expansion in young supernovae.

Findings

Many Type IIn SNe do not follow steady wind density profiles.

Some SNe show increasing or constant X-ray luminosity over time.

Lower luminosity SNe are more consistent with steady wind expansion.

Abstract

Massive stars lose mass in the form of stellar winds and outbursts. This material accumulates around the star. When the star explodes as a supernova (SN) the resulting shock wave expands within this circumstellar medium. The X-ray emission resulting from the interaction depends, among other parameters, on the density of this medium, and therefore the variation in the X-ray luminosity can be used to study the variation in the density structure of the medium. In this paper we explore the X-ray emission and lightcurves of all known SNe, in order to study the nature of the medium into which they are expanding. In particular we wish to investigate whether young SNe are expanding into a steady wind medium, as is most often assumed in the literature. We find that in the context of the theoretical arguments that have been generally used in the literature, many young SNe, and especially those of Type IIn, which are the brightest X-ray luminosity class, do not appear to be expanding into steady winds. Some IIns appear to have very steep X-ray luminosity declines, indicating density declines much steeper than r$^{-2}$. However, other IIns show a constant or even increasing X-ray luminosity over periods of months to years. Many other SNe do not appear to have declines consistent with expansion in a steady wind. SNe with lower X-ray luminosities appear to be more consistent with steady wind expansion, although the numbers are not large enough to make firm statistical comments. The numbers do indicate that the expansion and density structure of the circumstellar medium must be investigated before assumptions can be made of steady wind expansion. Unless a steady wind can be shown, mass-loss rates deduced using this assumption may need to be revised.