A Survey of Alkali Line Absorption in Exoplanetary Atmospheres

TL;DR

This study presents a detailed spectroscopic survey of four exoplanetary atmospheres, confirming sodium absorption in some cases and identifying potential targets for future atmospheric characterization.

Contribution

It provides a reanalysis of existing data with an independent pipeline, confirming previous sodium detections and exploring new potential absorption features in exoplanet atmospheres.

Findings

Confirmed sodium absorption in HD 189733b at a significant level.

Tentatively confirmed sodium in HD 209458b, with less certainty.

Identified potential sodium absorption in HD 149026b for future study.

Abstract

We obtained over 90 hours of spectroscopic observations of four exoplanetary systems with the Hobby-Eberly Telescope (HET). Observations were taken in transit and out of transit, and we analyzed the differenced spectra---i.e., the transmission spectra---to inspect it for absorption at the wavelengths of the neutral sodium (\ion{Na}{1}) doublet at $\lambda\lambda5889, 5895$ and neutral potassium (\ion{K}{1}) at $\lambda7698$. We used the transmission spectrum at \ion{Ca}{1} $\lambda6122$---which shows strong stellar absorption but is not an alkali metal resonance line that we expect to show significant absorption in these atmospheres---as a control line to examine our measurements for systematic errors. We use an empirical Monte Carlo method to quantity these systematic errors. In a reanalysis of the same dataset using a reduction and analysis pipeline that was derived independently, we confirm the previously seen \ion{Na}{1} absorption in HD 189733b at a level of $(-5.26\pm1.69)\times10^{-4}$ (the average value over a 12 \AA{} integration band to be consistent with previous authors). Additionally, we tentatively confirm the \ion{Na}{1} absorption seen in HD 209458b (independently by multiple authors) at a level of $(-2.63\pm0.81)\times10^{-4}$, though the interpretation is less clear. Furthermore, we find \ion{Na}{1} absorption of $(-3.16\pm2.06)\times10^{-4}$ at $<3\sigma$ in HD 149026b; features apparent in the transmission spectrum are consistent with real absorption and indicate this may be a good target for future observations to confirm. No other results (\ion{Na}{1} in HD 147506b and \ion{Ca}{1} and \ion{K}{1} in all four targets) are significant to $\geq 3\sigma$, although we observe some features that we argue are primarily artifacts.