Slowly balding black holes

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that black holes formed from collapsing neutron stars can retain magnetic flux tubes, challenging the traditional 'no hair' theorem by showing a slow, resistive process of magnetic flux loss.

Contribution

It introduces a topological constraint preventing magnetic flux from leaving the horizon during collapse and verifies this through 3D plasma simulations, revealing a slow flux loss process.

Findings

Black holes can conserve magnetic flux tubes after formation.

Flux loss occurs on resistive, long time scales, not instantaneously.

Simulations confirm the retention and slow dissipation of magnetic flux.

Abstract

The "no hair" theorem, a key result in General Relativity, states that an isolated black hole is defined by only three parameters: mass, angular momentum, and electric charge; this asymptotic state is reached on a light-crossing time scale. We find that the "no hair" theorem is not formally applicable for black holes formed from collapse of a rotating neutron star. Rotating neutron stars can self-produce particles via vacuum breakdown forming a highly conducting plasma magnetosphere such that magnetic field lines are effectively "frozen-in" the star both before and during collapse. In the limit of no resistivity, this introduces a topological constraint which prohibits the magnetic field from sliding off the newly-formed event horizon. As a result, during collapse of a neutron star into a black hole, the latter conserves the number of magnetic flux tubes $N_B = e \Phi_\infty /(\pi c \hbar)$, where $\Phi_\infty \approx 2 \pi^2 B_{NS} R_{NS}^3 /(P_{\rm NS} c)$ is the initial magnetic flux through the hemispheres of the progenitor and out to infinity. We test this theoretical result via three-dimensional general relativistic plasma simulations of rotating black holes that start with a neutron star dipole magnetic field with no currents initially present outside the event horizon. The black hole's magnetosphere subsequently relaxes to the split monopole magnetic field geometry with self-generated currents outside the event horizon. The dissipation of the resulting equatorial current sheet leads to a slow loss of the anchored flux tubes, a process that balds the black hole on long resistive time scales rather than the short light-crossing time scales expected from the vacuum "no-hair" theorem.