Generalized More Sums Than Differences Sets

TL;DR

This paper generalizes the concept of sum-dominant sets to multiple sums and differences, proving positive percentages of such sets exist, developing explicit constructions, and analyzing their limiting behaviors and generational properties.

Contribution

It extends previous work by generalizing sum-dominant sets to multiple sums and differences, providing explicit constructions, and analyzing their asymptotic and generational behaviors.

Findings

A positive percentage of sets are sum-dominant for all nontrivial sum/difference combinations.

Explicit constructions of such sets are provided.

Most sets are not k-generational for all k, despite positive percentages for each fixed k.

Abstract

A More Sums Than Differences (MSTD, or sum-dominant) set is a finite set $A\subset \mathbb{Z}$ such that $|A+A|<|A-A|$. Though it was believed that the percentage of subsets of $\{0,...,n\}$ that are sum-dominant tends to zero, in 2006 Martin and O'Bryant \cite{MO} proved a positive percentage are sum-dominant. We generalize their result to the many different ways of taking sums and differences of a set. We prove that $|\epsilon_1A+...+\epsilon_kA|>|\delta_1A+...+\delta_kA|$ a positive percent of the time for all nontrivial choices of $\epsilon_j,\delta_j\in \{-1,1\}$. Previous approaches proved the existence of infinitely many such sets given the existence of one; however, no method existed to construct such a set. We develop a new, explicit construction for one such set, and then extend to a positive percentage of sets. We extend these results further, finding sets that exhibit different behavior as more sums/differences are taken. For example, notation as above we prove that for any $m$, $|\epsilon_1A + ... + \epsilon_kA| - |\delta_1A + ... + \delta_kA| = m$ a positive percentage of the time. We find the limiting behavior of $kA=A+...+A$ for an arbitrary set $A$ as $k\to\infty$ and an upper bound of $k$ for such behavior to settle down. Finally, we say $A$ is $k$-generational sum-dominant if $A$, $A+A$, ...,$kA$ are all sum-dominant. Numerical searches were unable to find even a 2-generational set (heuristics indicate the probability is at most $10^{-9}$, and almost surely significantly less). We prove the surprising result that for any $k$ a positive percentage of sets are $k$-generational, and no set can be $k$-generational for all $k$.