Hall instability of solar flux tubes

TL;DR

This paper investigates how Hall drift can destabilize magnetic flux tubes in the solar atmosphere, potentially leading to turbulence and heating of the chromosphere, with implications for solar magnetic field dynamics.

Contribution

It presents a local stability analysis of Hall instability in solar flux tubes, revealing conditions under which magnetic fields become unstable in the photosphere and chromosphere.

Findings

Hall instability growth rate peaks at ~0.5 Mm for kilogauss fields.

Internetwork fields are unstable throughout the photosphere-chromosphere.

Hall instability can generate low-frequency turbulence contributing to chromospheric heating.

Abstract

The magnetic network which consists of vertical flux tubes located in intergranular lanes is dominated by Hall drift in the photosphere-lower chromosphere region ($\lesssim 1 Mm$). In the internetwork regions, Hall drift dominates above $0.25 Mm$ in the photosphere and below $2.5 Mm$ in the chromosphere. Although Hall drift does not cause any dissipation in the ambient plasma, it can destabilise the flux tubes and magnetic elements in the presence of azimuthal shear flow. The physical mechanism of this instability is quite simple: the shear flow twists the radial magnetic field and generates azimuthal field; torsional oscillations of the azimuthal field in turn generates the radial field completing feedback loop. The maximum growth rate of Hall instability is proportional to the absolute value of the shear gradient and is dependent on the ambient diffusivity. The diffusivity also determines the most unstable wavelength which is smaller for weaker fields. We apply the result of local stability analysis to the network and internetwork magnetic elements and show that the maximum growth rate for kilogauss field occurs around $0.5 Mm$ and decreases with increasing altitude. However, for a $120 G$ field, the maximum growth rate remains almost constant in the entire photosphere-lower chromosphere except in a small region of lower photosphere. For shear flow gradient $\sim 0.01 s^{-1}$, the Hall growth time is 10 minute near the footpoint. Therefore, network fields are likely to be unstable in the photosphere, whereas internetwork fields could be unstable in the entire photosphere-chromosphere. Thus the Hall instability can play an important role in generating low frequency turbulence which can heat the chromosphere.