Spatial structure increases the waiting time for cancer

TL;DR

This paper introduces a spatially structured model of cancer progression, revealing that spatial structure and clonal interference significantly delay cancer development and alter genetic diversity patterns.

Contribution

The study presents a novel spatial model of cancer evolution that incorporates clonal interference, contrasting with traditional well-mixed population models.

Findings

Spatial structure increases waiting time for cancer.

Clonal interference leads to a patchwork of clone sizes.

Genetic distance grows over a characteristic length scale.

Abstract

Cancer results from a sequence of genetic and epigenetic changes which lead to a variety of abnormal phenotypes including increased proliferation and survival of somatic cells, and thus, to a selective advantage of pre-cancerous cells. The notion of cancer progression as an evolutionary process has been experiencing increasing interest in recent years. Many efforts have been made to better understand and predict the progression to cancer using mathematical models; these mostly consider the evolution of a well-mixed cell population, even though pre-cancerous cells often evolve in highly structured epithelial tissues. We propose a novel model of cancer progression that considers a spatially structured cell population where clones expand via adaptive waves. This model is used to asses two different paradigms of asexual evolution that have been suggested to delineate the process of cancer progression. The standard scenario of periodic selection assumes that driver mutations are accumulated strictly sequentially over time. However, when the mutation supply is sufficiently high, clones may arise simultaneously on distinct genetic backgrounds, and clonal adaptation waves interfere with each other. We find that in the presence of clonal interference, spatial structure increases the waiting time for cancer, leads to a patchwork structure of non-uniformly sized clones, decreases the survival probability of virtually neutral (passenger) mutations, and that genetic distance begins to increase over a characteristic length scale, determined here. These characteristic features of clonal interference may help to predict the onset of cancers with pronounced spatial structure and to interpret spatially-sampled genetic data obtained from biopsies. Our estimates suggest that clonal interference likely occurs in the progressing colon cancer, and possibly other cancers where spatial structure matters.