Reply to "Comment on `Transition from Bose glass to a condensate of triplons in Tl$_{1-x}$K$_x$CuCl$_3$'"

TL;DR

This paper defends previous findings on magnetic-field-induced spin ordering in Tl$_{1-x}$K$_x$CuCl$_3$, providing experimental data and physics-based arguments against criticisms regarding the Bose glass to condensate transition of triplons.

Contribution

It offers a detailed rebuttal to prior criticism, reaffirming the interpretation of the phase transition as a Bose glass to condensate of triplons in the studied material.

Findings

Experimental data supports the Bose glass to condensate transition interpretation.

Arguments based on low-temperature specific heat challenge previous criticisms.

Reaffirmation of the magnetic-field-induced spin ordering in Tl$_{1-x}$K$_x$CuCl$_3$.

Abstract

Showing low-temperature specific heat and other experimental data and also on the basis of established physics, we argue against the comment made by Zheludev and H\"{u}vonnen criticizing our recent study on the magnetic-field-induced spin ordering and critical behavior in Tl$_{1-x}$K$_x$CuCl$_3$, which is described as the Bose glass-condensate transition of triplons.