The Brightest Cluster X-ray Sources

TL;DR

This paper proposes that bright X-ray sources in globular clusters are ultracompact X-ray binaries with neutron stars and white dwarfs, offering explanations for their luminosity, distribution, and specific sources like HLX-1.

Contribution

It introduces a model where ultracompact X-ray binaries explain bright sources previously thought to be black hole binaries, with detailed luminosity functions and predictions for observations.

Findings

Theoretical luminosity function matches observed distributions.

Predicted detection rates in elliptical galaxies align with observations.

HLX-1 could be an ultracompact X-ray binary or a more massive intermediate object.

Abstract

There have been several recent claims of black hole binaries in globular clusters. I show that these candidate systems could instead be ultracompact X-ray binaries (UCXBs) in which a neutron star accretes from a white dwarf. They would represent a slightly earlier evolutionary stage of known globular cluster UCXBs such as 4U 1820--30, with white dwarf masses $\sim 0.2\msun$, and orbital periods below 5 minutes. Accretion is slightly super--Eddington, and makes these systems ultraluminous sources (ULXs) with rather mild beaming factors $b \sim 0.3$. Their theoretical luminosity function flattens slightly just above $\le$ and then steepens at $\sim 3\le$. It predicts of order 2 detections in elliptical galaxies such as NGC 4472, as observed. The very bright X-ray source HLX--1 lies off the plane of its host S0a galaxy. If this is an indication of globular cluster membership, it could conceivably be a more extreme example of a UCXB with white dwarf mass $M_2 \simeq 0.34\msun$. The beaming here is tighter ($b \sim 2.5 - 9 \times 10^{-3}$), but the system's distance of 95 Mpc easily eliminates any need to invoke improbable alignment of the beam for detection. If its position instead indicates membership of a satellite dwarf galaxy, HLX-1 could have a much higher accretor mass $\sim 1000\msun$