Weight-conserving characterization of complex functional brain networks

TL;DR

This paper introduces new methods for analyzing complex, densely connected, weighted brain networks, addressing key methodological challenges to improve the reliability of functional brain network characterization.

Contribution

It generalizes modularity and centrality measures for fully connected weighted networks, detects degenerate high-modularity partitions, and proposes a null model for hypothesis testing.

Findings

Demonstrated degenerate high-modularity partitions in MRI networks

Found strong correlations between centrality measures in resting-state networks

Enhanced reliability of functional brain network analysis

Abstract

Complex functional brain networks are large networks of brain regions and functional brain connections. Statistical characterizations of these networks aim to quantify global and local properties of brain activity with a small number of network measures. Important functional network measures include measures of modularity (measures of the goodness with which a network is optimally partitioned into functional subgroups) and measures of centrality (measures of the functional influence of individual brain regions). Characterizations of functional networks are increasing in popularity, but are associated with several important methodological problems. These problems include the inability to characterize densely connected and weighted functional networks, the neglect of degenerate topologically distinct high-modularity partitions of these networks, and the absence of a network null model for testing hypotheses of association between observed nontrivial network properties and simple weighted connectivity properties. In this study we describe a set of methods to overcome these problems. Specifically, we generalize measures of modularity and centrality to fully connected and weighted complex networks, describe the detection of degenerate high-modularity partitions of these networks, and introduce a weighted-connectivity null model of these networks. We illustrate our methods by demonstrating degenerate high-modularity partitions and strong correlations between two complementary measures of centrality in resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) networks from the 1000 Functional Connectomes Project, an open-access repository of resting-state functional MRI datasets. Our methods may allow more sound and reliable characterizations and comparisons of functional brain networks across conditions and subjects.