Water deuterium fractionation in the low-mass protostar NGC1333-IRAS2A

TL;DR

This study measures water deuterium fractionation in the low-mass protostar NGC1333-IRAS2A, revealing higher HDO/H2O ratios than in comets, which suggests significant reprocessing of material during star and planet formation.

Contribution

First measurement of water deuterium fractionation in NGC1333-IRAS2A, comparing it to IRAS 16293-2422, and implications for chemical processing in star formation.

Findings

HDO/H2O ratio in the inner envelope exceeds 1%

Outer envelope HDO/H2O ratio ranges from 0.9% to 18%

Similar HDO abundances in two different protostars

Abstract

Although deuterium enrichment of water may provide an essential piece of information in the understanding of the formation of comets and protoplanetary systems, only a few studies up to now have aimed at deriving the HDO/H2O ratio in low-mass star forming regions. Previous studies of the molecular deuteration toward the solar-type class 0 protostar, IRAS 16293-2422, have shown that the D/H ratio of water is significantly lower than other grain-surface-formed molecules. It is not clear if this property is general or particular to this source. In order to see if the results toward IRAS 16293-2422 are particular, we aimed at studying water deuterium fractionation in a second low-mass solar-type protostar, NGC1333-IRAS2A. Using the 1-D radiative transfer code RATRAN, we analyzed five HDO transitions observed with the IRAM 30m, JCMT, and APEX telescopes. We assumed that the abundance profile of HDO in the envelope is a step function, with two different values in the inner warm (T>100 K) and outer cold (T<100 K) regions of the protostellar envelope. The inner and outer abundance of HDO is found to be well constrained at the 3 sigma level. The obtained HDO inner and outer fractional abundances are x_in=6.6e-8 - 1e-7 and x_out=9e-11 - 1.8e-9 (3 sigma). These values are close to those in IRAS 16293-2422, which suggests that HDO may be formed by the same mechanisms in these two solar-type protostars. Taking into account the (rather poorly constrained) H2O abundance profile deduced from Herschel observations, the derived HDO/H2O in the inner envelope is larger than 1% and in the outer envelope it is 0.9%-18%. These values are more than one order of magnitude higher than what is measured in comets. If the same ratios apply to the protosolar nebula, this would imply that there is some efficient reprocessing of the material between the protostellar and cometary phases. The H2O inner fractional [...]