Comment: How Should Indirect Evidence Be Used?

TL;DR

This paper discusses the importance of indirect evidence in statistical practice and emphasizes the need for better understanding of how statistical methods relate to scientific problems, suggesting a nuanced approach to using indirect evidence.

Contribution

It highlights the significance of indirect evidence and advocates for future research to clarify the connection between statistical methods and scientific questions.

Findings

Indirect evidence is crucial for statistical success.

Sometimes informal use of indirect evidence is preferable.

Future research should focus on linking statistical methods with scientific problems.

Abstract

Indirect evidence is crucial for successful statistical practice. Sometimes, however, it is better used informally. Future efforts should be directed toward understanding better the connection between statistical methods and scientific problems. [arXiv:1012.1161]