Modeling CO Emission: I. CO as a Column Density Tracer and the X-Factor in Molecular Clouds

TL;DR

This study investigates how CO emission traces molecular hydrogen in clouds, analyzing the relationship between CO intensity, column densities, and the X factor through simulations and radiative transfer calculations.

Contribution

It applies hydrodynamic simulations and radiative transfer models to understand CO as a tracer of H2 and the behavior of the X factor under various cloud conditions.

Findings

High CO abundance clouds show a threshold CO intensity around 65 K km/s.

The X factor remains nearly constant in Milky Way-like conditions.

In low CO abundance clouds, the X factor varies significantly, sometimes over 4 orders of magnitude.

Abstract

Theoretical and observational investigations have indicated that the abundance of carbon monoxide (CO) is very sensitive to intrinsic properties of the gaseous medium, such as density, metallicity, and the background UV field. In order to accurately interpret CO observations, it is thus important to understand how well CO traces the gas, which in molecular clouds (MCs) is predominantly molecular hydrogen (H2). Recent hydrodynamic simulations by Glover & Mac Low have explicitly followed the formation and destruction of molecules in model MCs under varying conditions, confirming that CO formation strongly depends on the cloud properties. Conversely, the H2 formation is primarily determined by the age of the MC. We apply radiative transfer calculations to these MC models in order to investigate the properties of CO line emission. We focus on integrated CO (J=1-0) intensities emerging from individual clouds, including its relationship to the total, H2, and CO column densities, as well as the "X factor," the ratio of H2 column density to CO intensity. Models with high CO abundances have a threshold CO intensity ~65 K km/s at sufficiently large extinctions. Clouds with low CO abundances show no such intensity thresholds. The distribution of H2 column densities are well described as log-normal functions, though the distributions of CO intensities and column densities are usually not log-normal. In general, the PDFs of the integrated intensity do not follow the distribution functions of CO column densities. In the model with Milky Way-like conditions, the X factor is in agreement with the near constant value determined from observations. In clouds with lower CO abundances the X factor can vary appreciably - sometimes by > 4 orders of magnitude. In models with high densities, the CO line is fully saturated, so that the X factor is directly proportional to the molecular column density.