Discerning Exoplanet Migration Models Using Spin-Orbit Measurements

TL;DR

This study uses Bayesian analysis of current exoplanet spin-orbit data to determine that a combination of planet-planet scattering and disk migration best explains observed misalignments, with implications for understanding planet migration processes.

Contribution

It introduces a Bayesian model comparison approach to distinguish between different exoplanet migration mechanisms using spin-orbit measurements.

Findings

Current data strongly favor a two-mode migration scenario.

Between 34% and 76% of close-in planets migrated via planet-planet scattering.

Additional measurements could significantly improve model confidence.

Abstract

We investigate the current sample of exoplanet spin-orbit measurements to determine whether a dominant planet migration channel can be identified, and at what confidence. We use the predictions of Kozai migration plus tidal friction (Fabrycky and Tremaine 2007) and planet-planet scattering (Nagasawa et al. 2008) as our misalignment models, and we allow for a fraction of intrinsically aligned systems, explainable by disk migration. Bayesian model comparison demonstrates that the current sample of 32 spin-orbit measurements strongly favors a two-mode migration scenario combining planet-planet scattering and disk migration over a single-mode Kozai migration scenario. Our analysis indicates that between 34% and 76% of close-in planets (95% confidence) migrated via planet-planet scattering. Separately analyzing the subsample of 12 stars with T_eff > 6250 K---which Winn et al. (2010) predict to be the only type of stars to maintain their primordial misalignments---we find that the data favor a single-mode scattering model over Kozai with 81% confidence. We also assess the number of additional hot star spin-orbit measurements that will likely be necessary to provide a more confident model selection, finding that an additional 20-30 measurements has a >50% chance of resulting in a 95%-confident model selection, if the current model selection is correct. While we test only the predictions of particular Kozai and scattering migration models in this work, our methods may be used to test the predictions of any other spin-orbit misaligning mechanism.