Surface convection and red giants radii measurements

TL;DR

This study investigates whether the characteristic length scales used in convection models need adjustment for red giants, using observational data and two convection theories, leading to improved stellar models that better match observations.

Contribution

It demonstrates that reducing the solar convection length scale improves the modeling of red giant radii and temperatures, aligning models more closely with observations and seismic data.

Findings

Reduced solar convection length scale improves RGB models

Models match observed radii and temperatures better

Enhanced agreement with seismic constraints

Abstract

The phenomenological models of convection use characteristic length scales they do not determine but that are chosen to fit solar or stellar observations. We investigate if changes of these length scales are required between the Sun and low mass stars on the red giant branch (RGB). The question is addressed jointly in the frameworks of the mixing length theory and of the full spectrum of turbulence model. For both models, the convective length scale is assumed to be a fixed fraction of the local pressure scale height. We use constraints coming from the observed effective temperatures and linear radii independently. We rely on a sample of 38 nearby giants and subgiants for which surface temperatures and luminosities are known accurately and the radii are determined through interferometry to better than 10%. For the few cases where the stellar masses were determined by asteroseismological measurements, we computed dedicated models. First we calibrate the solar models. Then, with the same physics, we compute RGB models for masses between 0.9 Mo and 2.5 Mo and metallicities ranging from $\rm [Fe/H]=-0.34$ to solar. The evolution is followed up to 1000 Lo. A special attention is given to the opacities and to the non grey atmosphere models used as boundary conditions for which the model of convection is the same as in the interior. We find that for both the mixing length theory and the full spectrum of turbulence model the characteristic solar length scale for convection has to be slightly reduced to fit the lower edge of the observed RGB. The corresponding models also better match the expected mass distribution on the RGB and are in better agreement to the seismic constraints. These results are robust whether effective temperatures determined spectroscopically or radii determined interferometrically are used.