Modelling the shapes of the largest gravitationally bound objects

TL;DR

This paper develops an analytic model combining ellipsoidal collapse physics with excursion set theory to better understand dark matter halo shapes, providing insights into their evolution and mass dependence.

Contribution

It introduces a new analytic approximation for nonlinear halo shape evolution and a planar axis ratio representation, improving understanding of halo shape dynamics.

Findings

Model matches the minor-to-intermediate axis ratio distribution well.

Predicts high-mass halos are more spherical, aligning with recent observations.

Disagrees with some previous studies on minor-to-major axis ratios.

Abstract

We combine the physics of the ellipsoidal collapse model with the excursion set theory to study the shapes of dark matter halos. In particular, we develop an analytic approximation to the nonlinear evolution that is more accurate than the Zeldovich approximation; we introduce a planar representation of halo axis ratios, which allows a concise and intuitive description of the dynamics of collapsing regions and allows one to relate the final shape of a halo to its initial shape; we provide simple physical explanations for some empirical fitting formulae obtained from numerical studies. Comparison with simulations is challenging, as there is no agreement about how to define a non-spherical gravitationally bound object. Nevertheless, we find that our model matches the conditional minor-to-intermediate axis ratio distribution rather well, although it disagrees with the numerical results in reproducing the minor-to-major axis ratio distribution. In particular, the mass dependence of the minor-to-major axis distribution appears to be the opposite to what is found in many previous numerical studies, where low-mass halos are preferentially more spherical than high-mass halos. In our model, the high-mass halos are predicted to be more spherical, consistent with results based on a more recent and elaborate halo finding algorithm, and with observations of the mass dependence of the shapes of early-type galaxies. We suggest that some of the disagreement with some previous numerical studies may be alleviated if we consider only isolated halos.