The cooling phase of Type-I X-ray bursts in 4U 1636-53

TL;DR

This study analyzes ~300 X-ray bursts from 4U 1636-53, revealing that the cooling phase flux-temperature relation varies with burst type and suggesting differences in atmospheric composition and fuel type.

Contribution

It provides a detailed classification of burst types and demonstrates that the flux-temperature relation deviates from the canonical model, indicating complex atmospheric and fuel composition effects.

Findings

Different flux-temperature relations for PRE and non-PRE bursts

Hard non-PRE bursts ignite in hydrogen-rich atmospheres

Metal abundance decreases during burst decay

Abstract

Time-resolved spectra during the cooling phase of thermonuclear X-ray bursts in low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) can be used to measure the radii and masses of neutron stars. We analyzed ~ 300 bursts of the LMXB 4U 1636-53 using data from the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer. We divided the bursts in three groups, photospheric radius expansion (PRE), hard non-PRE and soft non-PRE bursts, based on the properties of the bursts and the state of the source at the time of the burst. For the three types of bursts, we found that the average relation between the bolometric flux and the temperature during the cooling phase of the bursts is significantly different from the canonical $F \propto T^4$ relation that is expected if the apparent emitting area on the surface of the neutron star remains constant as the flux decreases during the decay of the bursts. We also found that a single power law cannot fit the average flux-temperature relation for any of the three types of bursts, and that the flux-temperature relation for the three types of bursts is significantly different. Finally, for the three types of bursts, the temperature distribution at different flux levels during the decay of the bursts is significantly different. From the above we conclude that hard non-PRE bursts ignite in a hydrogen-rich atmosphere, whereas for soft non-PRE and PRE bursts the fuel is helium-rich. We further conclude that the metal abundance in the neutron star atmosphere decreases as the bursts decay, probably because the heavy elements sink faster in the atmosphere than H and He.