The transition from quasar radio-loud to radio-quiet state in the framework of the black hole scalability hypothesis

TL;DR

This study investigates the transition of certain quasars from radio-loud to radio-quiet states, supporting the black hole scalability hypothesis by linking AGN evolution to X-ray binary states through high-resolution radio observations.

Contribution

It provides observational evidence of AGN state transitions consistent with XRB analogs, using milliarcsecond radio imaging to analyze quasar nuclei and lobe asymmetries.

Findings

Quasars show no core-jet structures typical of radio-loud AGNs.

Radio lobes' asymmetry is due to orientation and time lag effects.

Transition from very high to high/soft state in AGNs is observed.

Abstract

There are several lines of evidence that active galactic nuclei (AGN) can be regarded as scaled-up X-ray binaries (XRB). The timescales of the evolutionary phenomena in these two classes are proportional to the black hole (BH) masses. Consequently, unlike in the case of XRBs, the evolution of AGNs is too slow to be followed directly. What could be done, however, is to assign particular types of active galaxies to different evolutionary stages observable in XRBs. We studied such an assignment for three quasars with clear signatures of a recent transition from the radio-loud to the radio-quiet state. The quasars we investigated have large-scale radio lobes that are clearly asymmetric -- one lobe is of Fanaroff-Riley II type, while the other one is a diffuse relic devoid of a hotspot. We suggest that the prime cause of the asymmetry of these radio sources is that the nuclei of their host galaxies currently produce no jets. To prove that, we observed them with milliarcsecond resolution to check if they are similar to those in radio-quiet quasars. The observations carried out with the EVN revealed that the nuclei of the quasars under investigation are not of a core-jet type that is characteristic for radio-loud, lobe-dominated quasars. It follows that the lobes are no longer fuelled and that the apparent asymmetry results from the orientation, which causes a time lag of the order of 10^6 years between their images: the lobe perceived as a relic is nearer than the lobe with a hotspot and so it is observed in a later stage of the decay. The three AGNs under investigation were radio-loud earlier, but now they have switched to the radio-quiet state. In the framework of the XRB/AGN unification, the above means that they have left the very high state and have moved now to the high/soft state. (abridged)