Selection of ULIRGs in Infrared and Submm Surveys

TL;DR

This study analyzes how different infrared and submillimeter surveys detect ULIRGs across redshifts, revealing biases towards certain dust temperatures and challenging the applicability of local temperature-luminosity relations at high redshift.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive assessment of survey selection effects on ULIRG temperature detection and proposes that high-redshift ULIRG evolution is temperature-dependent, not solely due to an evolving L-T relation.

Findings

Short wavelength surveys detect a wide temperature range of ULIRGs.

Long wavelength surveys favor colder ULIRGs, even at low redshift.

High-redshift ULIRG temperature distribution differs from local universe, not explained by local L-T relation.

Abstract

We examine the selection characteristics of infrared and sub-mm surveys with IRAS, Spitzer, BLAST, Herschel and SCUBA and identify the range of dust temperatures these surveys are sensitive to, for galaxies in the ULIRG luminosity range (12<log(LIR)<13), between z=0 and z=4. We find that the extent of the redshift range over which surveys are unbiased is a function of the wavelength of selection, flux density limit and ULIRG luminosity. Short wavelength (<200{\mu}m) surveys with IRAS, Spitzer/MIPS and Herschel/PACS are sensitive to all SED types in a large temperature interval (17-87K), over a substantial fraction of their accessible redshift range. On the other hand, long wavelength (>200{\mu}m) surveys with BLAST, Herschel/ SPIRE and SCUBA are significantly more sensitive to cold ULIRGs, disfavouring warmer SEDs even at low redshifts. We evaluate observations in the context of survey selection effects, finding that the lack of cold ULIRGs in the local (z<0.1) Universe is not a consequence of selection and that the range of ULIRG temperatures seen locally is only a subset of a much larger range which exists at high redshift. We demonstrate that the local luminosity-temperature (L-T) relation, which indicates that more luminous sources are also hotter, is not applicable in the distant Universe when extrapolated to the ULIRG regime, because the scatter in observed temperatures is too large. Finally, we show that the difference between the ULIRG temperature distributions locally and at high redshift is not the result of galaxies becoming colder due to an L-T relation which evolves as a function of redshift. Instead, they are consistent with a picture where the evolution of the infrared luminosity function is temperature dependent, i.e. cold galaxies evolve at a faster rate than their warm counterparts.