Radiative emission of solar features in the Ca II K line: comparison of measurements and models

TL;DR

This study compares observed radiative emissions of various solar features in the Ca II K line with NLTE spectral synthesis models, revealing insights into the accuracy of CRD and PRD calculations and the influence of atmospheric models.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of measurements and models for solar Ca II K line emissions, evaluating the effects of different radiative transfer assumptions and atmospheric models.

Findings

CRD calculations with recent models slightly better match quiet Sun measurements.

PRD calculations on earlier models also reproduce measurements well.

Discrepancies decrease when accounting for straylight effects.

Abstract

We study the radiative emission of various types of solar features, such as quiet Sun, enhanced network, plage, and bright plage regions, identified on filtergrams taken in the Ca II K line. We analysed fulldisk images obtained with the PSPT, by using three interference filters that sample the Ca II K line with different bandpasses. We studied the dependence of the radiative emission of disk features on the filter bandpass. We also performed a NLTE spectral synthesis of the Ca II K line integrated over the bandpass of PSPT filters. The synthesis was carried out by utilizing both the PRD and CRD with the most recent set of semi empirical atmosphere models in the literature and some earlier atmosphere models. We measured the CLV of intensity values for various solar features identified on PSPT images and compared the results obtained with those derived from the synthesis. We find that CRD calculations derived using the most recent quiet Sun model, on average, reproduce the measured values of the quiet Sun regions slightly more accurately than PRD computations with the same model. This may reflect that the utilized atmospheric model was computed assuming CRD. Calculations with PRD on earlier quiet Sun model atmospheres reproduce measured quantities with a similar accuracy as to that achieved here by applying CRD to the recent model. We also find that the median contrast values measured for most of the identified bright features, disk positions, and filter widths are, on average, a factor 1.9 lower than those derived from PRD simulations performed using the recent bright feature models. The discrepancy between measured and modeled values decreases by 12% after taking into account straylight effects on PSPT images. PRD computations on either the most recent or the earlier atmosphere models of bright features reproduce measurements from plage and bright plage regions with a similar accuracy.