The barium isotopic mixture for the metal-poor subgiant star HD140283

TL;DR

This study measures the barium isotope mixture in the metal-poor star HD140283, revealing a predominantly s-process signature that challenges current nucleosynthesis theories, and highlights the need for 3D modeling approaches.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed Ba isotope ratio measurement in HD140283 using high-quality spectra and chi^2 analysis, questioning the adequacy of 1D LTE models for such analysis.

Findings

Ba isotope ratio indicates a pure s-process signature (fodd=0.02±0.06).

New upper limits on star's rotation and Eu abundance were established.

Results challenge the current understanding of heavy element nucleosynthesis in metal-poor stars.

Abstract

Current theory regarding heavy element nucleosynthesis in metal-poor environments states that the r-process would be dominant. The star HD140283 has been the subject of debate after it appeared in some studies to be dominated by the s-process. We provide an independent measure of the Ba isotope mixture in HD140283 using an extremely high quality spectrum and an extensive chi^2 analysis. We exploit hyperfine splitting of the BaII 4554 \AA\ and 4934 \AA\ resonance lines in an effort to constrain the isotope ratio in 1D LTE. Using the code ATLAS in conjunction with KURUCZ06 model atmospheres we analyse 93 Fe lines to determine the star's macroturbulence. With this information we construct a grid of Ba synthetic spectra and, using a \chi^2 code, fit these to our observed data to determine the isotopic ratio, fodd, which represents the ratio of odd to even isotopes. We also analyse the Eu lines. We set a new upper limit of the rotation of HD140283 at vsin{i}\leq3.9\kms, a new upper limit on [Eu/H] < -2.80 and abundances [Fe/H] = -2.59\pm0.09, [Ba/H] = -3.46\pm0.11. This leads to a new lower limit on [Ba/Eu] > -0.66. We find that, in the framework of a 1D LTE analysis, the isotopic ratios of Ba in HD140283 indicate fodd=0.02\pm0.06, a purely s-process signature. This implies that observations and analysis do not validate currently accepted theory. We speculate that a 1D code, due to simplifying assumptions, is not adequate when dealing with observations with high levels of resolution and S/N because of the turbulent motions associated with a 3D stellar atmosphere. New approaches to analysing isotopic ratios, in particular 3D hydrodynamics, need to be considered when dealing with the levels of detail required to properly determine them. However published 3D results exacerbate the disagreement between theory and observation.