On detectability of Zeeman broadening in optical spectra of F- and G-dwarfs

TL;DR

This study assesses the detectability of Zeeman broadening in optical spectra of sun-like stars, highlighting the influence of temperature components on magnetic field measurements and demonstrating the challenges in distinguishing magnetic signals.

Contribution

It introduces a detailed analysis of Zeeman broadening detectability using LTE spectral line inversion with multiple temperature component models, revealing model dependence and potential ambiguities.

Findings

Upper limits of 200 G for the Sun and 150 G for 61 Vir.

Evidence of ~500 G magnetic field in 59 Vir.

Temperature component assumptions significantly affect magnetic field estimates.

Abstract

We investigate the detectability of Zeeman broadening in optical Stokes I spectra of slowly rotating sun-like stars. To this end, we apply the LTE spectral line inversion package SPINOR to very-high quality CES data and explore how fit quality depends on the average magnetic field, Bf . One-component (OC) and two-component (TC) models are adopted. In OC models, the entire surface is assumed to be magnetic. Under this assumption, we determine formal 3{\sigma} upper limits on the average magnetic field of 200 G for the Sun, and 150 G for 61 Vir (G6V). Evidence for an average magnetic field of ~ 500 G is found for 59 Vir (G0V), and of ~ 1000 G for HD 68456 (F6V). A distinction between magnetic and non-magnetic regions is made in TC models, while assuming a homogeneous distribution of both components. In our TC inversions of 59 Vir, we investigate three cases: both components have equal temperatures; warm magnetic regions; cool magnetic regions. Our TC model with equal temperatures does not yield significant improvement over OC inversions for 59 Vir. The resulting Bf values are consistent for both. Fit quality is significantly improved, however, by using two components of different temperatures. The inversions for 59 Vir that assume different temperatures for the two components yield results consistent with 0 - 450 G at the formal 3{\sigma} confidence level. We thus find a model dependence of our analysis and demonstrate that the influence of an additional temperature component can dominate over the Zeeman broadening signature, at least in optical data. Previous comparable analyses that neglected effects due to multiple temperature components may be prone to the same ambiguities.