Comparative Spectra of Oxygen-Rich vs. Carbon-Rich Circumstellar Shells: VY Canis Majoris and IRC+10216 at 215-285 GHz

TL;DR

This study compares the molecular compositions of oxygen-rich and carbon-rich circumstellar shells using a sensitive 1 mm spectral survey, revealing distinct chemistries and new molecular detections in VY CMa and IRC+10216.

Contribution

First millimeter-wave chemical characterization of an oxygen-rich circumstellar shell, highlighting differences from carbon-rich environments and discovering new molecular features.

Findings

VY CMa dominated by SO2 and SiS molecules

IRC+10216 shows greater molecular complexity with carbon-based species

New water maser and vibrationally-excited molecules detected

Abstract

A sensitive (1{\sigma} rms at 1 MHz resolution ~3 mK) 1 mm spectral line survey (214.5-285.5 GHz) of VY Canis Majoris (VY CMa) and IRC+10216 has been conducted to compare the chemistries of oxygen and carbon-rich circumstellar envelopes. This study was carried out using the Submillimeter Telescope (SMT) of the Arizona Radio Observatory (ARO) with a new ALMA-type receiver. This survey is the first to chemically characterize an O-rich circumstellar shell at millimeter wavelengths. In VY CMa, 128 emission features were detected arising from 18 different molecules, and in IRC+10216, 720 lines were observed, assigned to 32 different species. The 1 mm spectrum of VY CMa is dominated by SO2 and SiS; in IRC +10216, C4H and SiC2 are the most recurrent species. Ten molecules were common to both sources: CO, SiS, SiO, CS, CN, HCN, HNC, NaCl, PN, and HCO+. Sulfur plays an important role in VY CMa, but saturated/unsaturated carbon dominates the molecular content of IRC+10216, producing CH2NH, for example. Although the molecular complexity of IRC+10216 is greater, VY CMa supports a unique "inorganic" chemistry leading to the oxides PO, AlO, and AlOH. Only diatomic and triatomic compounds were observed in VY CMa, while species with 4 or more atoms are common in IRC+10216, reflecting carbon's ability to form strong multiple bonds, unlike oxygen. In VY CMa, a new water maser (v_2=2) has been found, as well as vibrationally-excited NaCl. Toward IRC+10216, vibrationally-excited CCH was detected for the first time.