Illusions in the Ring Model of visual orientation selectivity

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the Ring Model of visual orientation selectivity, revealing neural illusions predicted by the model and providing a mathematical framework to compare its predictions with experimental data.

Contribution

It introduces an invariant polynomial reformulation of the Ring Model and demonstrates the existence of neural illusions, offering a new way to test the model experimentally.

Findings

Some tuning curves are not stimulus-tuned, interpreted as neural illusions.

Neural illusions can be induced by simple stimuli in simulations.

Theoretical analysis helps specify model parameters consistent with experiments.

Abstract

The Ring Model of orientation tuning is a dynamical model of a hypercolumn of visual area V1 in the human neocortex that has been designed to account for the experimentally observed orientation tuning curves by local, i.e., cortico-cortical computations. The tuning curves are stationary, i.e. time independent, solutions of this dynamical model. One important assumption underlying the Ring Model is that the LGN input to V1 is weakly tuned to the retinal orientation and that it is the local computations in V1 that sharpen this tuning. Because the equations that describe the Ring Model have built-in equivariance properties in the synaptic weight distribution with respect to a particular group acting on the retinal orientation of the stimulus, the model in effect encodes an infinite number of tuning curves that are arbitrarily translated with respect to each other. By using the Orbit Space Reduction technique we rewrite the model equations in canonical form as functions of polynomials that are invariant with respect to the action of this group. This allows us to combine equivariant bifurcation theory with an efficient numerical continuation method in order to compute the tuning curves predicted by the Ring Model. Surprisingly some of these tuning curves are not tuned to the stimulus. We interpret them as neural illusions and show numerically how they can be induced by simple dynamical stimuli. These neural illusions are important biological predictions of the model. If they could be observed experimentally this would be a strong point in favour of the Ring Model. We also show how our theoretical analysis allows to very simply specify the ranges of the model parameters by comparing the model predictions with published experimental observations.