An optimal path to transition in a duct

TL;DR

This study investigates the nonlinear optimal disturbances leading to transition in a square duct flow, identifying specific traveling waves and unstable solutions that mediate laminar-turbulent transition.

Contribution

It introduces a variational approach to find optimal traveling waves and links these to the edge state mediating transition, advancing understanding of bypass transition mechanisms.

Findings

Optimal traveling wave solutions resemble minimal defects.

Edge state simulations reveal unstable solutions mediating transition.

Nonlinear interactions of disturbances trigger rapid breakdown.

Abstract

This paper is concerned with the transition of the laminar flow in a duct of square cross-section. Like in the similar case of the pipe flow, the motion is linearly stable for all Reynolds numbers, rendering this flow a suitable candidate for a study of the 'bypass' path to turbulence. It has already been shown \citep{Biau_JFM_2008} that the classical linear optimal perturbation problem, yielding optimal disturbances in the form of longitudinal vortices, fails to provide an 'optimal' path to turbulence, i.e. optimal perturbations do not elicit a significant nonlinear response from the flow. Previous simulations have also indicated that a pair of travelling waves generates immediately, by nonlinear quadratic interactions, an unstable mean flow distortion, responsible for rapid breakdown. By the use of functions quantifying the sensitivity of the motion to deviations in the base flow, the 'optimal' travelling wave associated to its specific defect is found by a variational approach. This optimal solution is then integrated in time and shown to display a qualitative similarity to the so-called 'minimal defect', for the same parameters. Finally, numerical simulations of a 'edge state' are conducted, to identify an unstable solution which mediates laminar-turbulent transition and relate it to results of the optimisation procedure.