Pre-main sequence stars with disks in the Eagle Nebula observed in scattered light

TL;DR

This study investigates a subset of disk-bearing pre-main sequence stars in the Eagle Nebula, revealing that scattered light affects their observed properties and complicates age and disk diagnostics.

Contribution

It demonstrates that scattered light influences the physical parameter estimation of young stars with disks, and introduces a NIR disk diagnostic for identifying such stars.

Findings

Scattered light alters V-I colors, making age estimates unreliable.

A new NIR diagnostic effectively identifies stars with disks, even with moderate excesses.

Scattering impacts the interpretation of optical and NIR photometry of young stellar objects.

Abstract

NGC6611 and its parental cloud, the Eagle Nebula (M16), are well-studied star-forming regions, thanks to their large content of both OB stars and stars with disks and the observed ongoing star formation. We identified 834 disk-bearing stars associated with the cloud, after detecting their excesses in NIR bands from J band to 8.0 micron. In this paper, we study in detail the nature of a subsample of disk-bearing stars that show peculiar characteristics. They appear older than the other members in the V vs. V-I diagram, and/or they have one or more IRAC colors at pure photospheric values, despite showing NIR excesses, when optical and infrared colors are compared. We confirm the membership of these stars to M16 by a spectroscopic analysis. The physical properties of these stars with disks are studied by comparing their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) with the SEDs predicted by models of T-Tauri stars with disks and envelopes. We show that the age of these stars estimated from the V vs. V-I diagram is unreliable since their V-I colors are altered by the light scattered by the disk into the line of sight. Only in a few cases their SEDs are compatible with models with excesses in V band caused by optical veiling. Candidate members with disks and photospheric IRAC colors are selected by the used NIR disk diagnostic, which is sensitive to moderate excesses, such as those produced by disks with low masses. In 1/3 of these cases, scattering of stellar flux by the disks can also be invoked. The photospheric light scattered by the disk grains into the line of sight can affect the derivation of physical parameters of ClassII stars from photometric optical and NIR data. Besides, the disks diagnostic we defined are useful for selecting stars with disks, even those with moderate excesses or whose optical colors are altered by veiling or photospheric scattered light.