Atmospheric mass loss by stellar wind from planets around main sequence M stars

TL;DR

This paper develops an analytic model to estimate atmospheric mass loss from planets around M dwarf stars due to stellar wind interaction, focusing on planets with no magnetic field and considering different stellar activity scenarios.

Contribution

It introduces a quick test-model for atmospheric mass loss that accounts for stellar wind properties, planetary characteristics, and magnetic field absence, applicable to various stellar activity levels.

Findings

Planets without magnetic fields in early M dwarfs may retain atmospheres for over 1 Gyr.

Late M dwarfs' planets likely lose atmospheres within 1 Gyr due to prolonged stellar activity.

The model highlights the importance of magnetic fields in protecting planetary atmospheres.

Abstract

We present an analytic model for the interaction between planetary atmospheres and stellar winds from main sequence M stars, with the purpose of obtaining a quick test-model that estimates the timescale for total atmospheric mass loss due to this interaction. Planets in the habitable zone of M dwarfs may be tidally locked and may have weak magnetic fields, because of this we consider the extreme case of planets with no magnetic field. The model gives the planetary atmosphere mass loss rate as a function of the stellar wind and planetary properties (mass, atmospheric pressure and orbital distance) and an entrainment efficiency coefficient $\alpha$. We use a mixing layer model to explore two different cases: a time-independent stellar mass loss and a stellar mass loss rate that decreases with time. For both cases we consider planetary masses within the range of $1\to10$ M$_{\oplus}$ and atmospheric pressures with values of 1, 5 and 10 atm. For the time dependent case, planets without magnetic field in the habitable zone of M dwarfs with initial stellar mass losses of $\leq \dot{M}_{w} < 10^{-11}$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$, may retain their atmospheres for at least 1 Gyr. This case may be applied to early spectral type M dwarfs (earlier than M5). Studies have shown that late type M dwarfs (later than M5) may be active for long periods of time ($\geq 4$Gyr), and because of that our model with constant stellar mass loss rate may be more accurate. For these stars most planets may have lost their atmospheres in 1 Gyr or less because most of the late type M dwarfs are expected to be active. We emphasize that our model only considers planets without magnetic fields. Clearly we must expect a higher resistance to atmospheric erosion if we include the presence of a magnetic field.