Proviola: A Tool for Proof Re-animation

TL;DR

Proviola introduces a novel method for recording, replaying, and discussing proof interactions in formal proof systems, enhancing proof review and collaboration without requiring full proof assistant setups.

Contribution

The paper presents the proof movie concept, a new data structure, and a prototype implementation for proof interaction recording and replay, improving proof review and collaboration.

Findings

Proof movies enable proof review without full PA setup

The camera captures interactive sessions for replay and discussion

Movies facilitate collaborative proof analysis and annotation

Abstract

To improve on existing models of interaction with a proof assistant (PA), in particular for storage and replay of proofs, we in- troduce three related concepts, those of: a proof movie, consisting of frames which record both user input and the corresponding PA response; a camera, which films a user's interactive session with a PA as a movie; and a proviola, which replays a movie frame-by-frame to a third party. In this paper we describe the movie data structure and we discuss a proto- type implementation of the camera and proviola based on the ProofWeb system. ProofWeb uncouples the interaction with a PA via a web- interface (the client) from the actual PA that resides on the server. Our camera films a movie by "listening" to the ProofWeb communication. The first reason for developing movies is to uncouple the reviewing of a formal proof from the PA used to develop it: the movie concept enables users to discuss small code fragments without the need to install the PA or to load a whole library into it. Other advantages include the possibility to develop a separate com- mentary track to discuss or explain the PA interaction. We assert that a combined camera+proviola provides a generic layer between a client (user) and a server (PA). Finally we claim that movies are the right type of data to be stored in an encyclopedia of formalized mathematics, based on our experience in filming the Coq standard library.