Spherical collapse model in dark energy cosmologies

TL;DR

This paper develops a robust spherical collapse model for dark energy cosmologies, providing insights into structure formation and showing that key parameters are largely insensitive to dark energy variations.

Contribution

It introduces a numerically stable, conceptually clear approach to the spherical collapse model applicable to various dark energy scenarios, including early dark energy.

Findings

Parameters δ_c and Δ_V are similar across dark energy models.

Structure abundance is insensitive to dark energy differences.

Revises previous conclusions on early dark energy effects.

Abstract

We study the spherical collapse model for several dark energy scenarios using the fully nonlinear differential equation for the evolution of the density contrast within homogeneous spherical overdensities derived from Newtonian hydrodynamics. While mathematically equivalent to the more common approach based on the differential equation for the radius of the perturbation, this approach has substantial conceptual as well as numerical advantages. Among the most important are that no singularities at early times appear, which avoids numerical problems in particular in applications to cosmologies with dynamical and early dark energy, and that the assumption of time-reversal symmetry can easily be dropped where it is not strictly satisfied. We use this approach to derive the two parameters characterising the spherical-collapse model, i.e.~the linear density threshold for collapse $\delta_\mathrm{c}$ and the virial overdensity $\Delta_\mathrm{V}$, for a broad variety of dark-energy models and to reconsider these parameters in cosmologies with early dark energy. We find that, independently of the model under investigation, $\delta_\mathrm{c}$ and $\Delta_\mathrm{V}$ are always very close to the values obtained for the standard $\Lambda$CDM model, arguing that the abundance of and the mean density within non-linear structures are quite insensitive to the differences between dark-energy cosmologies. Regarding early dark energy, we thus arrive at a different conclusion than some earlier papers, including one from our group, and we explain why.