A comparative analysis of Painlev\'e, Lax Pair, and Similarity Transformation methods in obtaining the integrability conditions of nonlinear Schr\"odinger equations

TL;DR

This paper compares Painlevé, Lax Pair, and Similarity Transformation methods for deriving integrability conditions of nonautonomous nonlinear Schrödinger equations, highlighting differences in restrictions on coefficients and potentials.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparison of three methods, extending integrability conditions to space-dependent coefficients and higher dimensions.

Findings

Painlevé conditions restrict coefficients to be space-independent

Lax Pair and Similarity methods allow space-dependent coefficients

General conditions include higher spatial dimensions

Abstract

We derive the integrability conditions of nonautonomous nonlinear Schr$\rm\ddot o$dinger equations using the Lax Pair and Similarity Transformation methods. We present a comparative analysis of these integrability conditions with those of the Painlev$\rm\acute{e}$ method. We show that while the Painlev$\rm\acute{e}$ integrability conditions restrict the dispersion, nonlinearity, and dissipation/gain coefficients to be space-independent and the external potential to be only a quadratic function of position, the Lax Pair and the Similarity Transformation methods allow for space-dependent coefficients and an external potential that is not restricted to the quadratic form. The integrability conditions of the Painlev$\rm\acute{e}$ method are retrieved as a special case of our general integrability conditions. We also derive the integrability conditions of nonautonomous nonlinear Schr$\rm\ddot o$dinger equations for two- and three-spacial dimensions.