Galaxy-Galaxy Lensing by Non-Spherical Haloes I:Theoretical Considerations

TL;DR

This paper uses Monte Carlo simulations to analyze how multiple deflections affect galaxy-galaxy lensing signals from non-spherical dark matter haloes, revealing significant observational biases.

Contribution

It demonstrates the importance of accounting for multiple deflections in interpreting galaxy-galaxy lensing data involving non-spherical haloes.

Findings

Observed shear ratios are suppressed compared to intrinsic expectations.

Lensing of foreground galaxies alters observed symmetry axes.

Effects cannot be mitigated by simple data filtering.

Abstract

We use Monte Carlo simulations to investigate the theory of galaxy-galaxy lensing by non-spherical dark matter haloes. The simulations include a careful accounting of the effects of multiple deflections. In a typical data set where the mean tangential shear of sources with redshifts zs ~ 0.6 is measured with respect to the observed symmetry axes of foreground galaxies with redshifts zl ~ 0.3, the signature of anisotropic galaxy-galaxy lensing differs substantially from the expectation that one would have in the absence of multiple deflections. The observed ratio of the mean tangential shears, g+/g-, is strongly suppressed compared to the function that one would measure if the intrinsic symmetry axes of the foreground galaxies were known. Depending upon the characteristic masses of the lenses, the observed ratio of the mean tangential shears may be consistent with an isotropic signal (despite the fact that the lenses are non-spherical), or it may even be reversed from the expected signal (i.e., the mean tangential shear for sources close to the observed minor axes of the lenses may exceed the mean tangential shear for sources close to the observed major axes of the lenses). These effects are caused primarily by the fact that the lens galaxies have, themselves, been lensed and therefore the observed symmetry axes of the lenses differ from their intrinsic symmetry axes. The effects of lensing of the foreground galaxies on the observed function g+/g- cannot be eliminated by the rejection of foreground galaxies with small image ellipticities, nor by focusing the analysis on sources that are located very close to the observed symmetry axes of the foreground galaxies. We conclude that any attempt to use a measurement of g+/g- to constrain the shapes of dark matter galaxy haloes must include Monte Carlo simulations that take multiple deflections properly into account.