A Re-Evaluation of the Evolved Stars in the Globular Cluster M13

TL;DR

This study provides a detailed photometric analysis of M13's evolved stars, clarifying HB star evolution, and supports primordial helium abundance consistent with theoretical models, while addressing previous discrepancies in distance measurements.

Contribution

It offers new insights into the evolutionary status of HB stars in M13 and revisits helium abundance estimates, resolving prior disagreements and clarifying the nature of evolved stars.

Findings

HB stars redder than the primary group are evolved

The HB population is near the 'knee' in CMDs, affecting appearance

M13's helium ratio aligns with primordial helium abundance Y_P = 0.245

Abstract

We present photometry for all bright red giant branch (RGB), horizontal branch (HB), and asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars within 10' of the center of M13. We find support for the idea that the population of HB stars redder than the primary group are noticeably evolved, which resolves a disagreement between distance moduli derived from the tip of the RGB and from stars near the instability strip. The sharp cut at the red end of the HB provides strong evidence that stars from the dominant HB group must still be undergoing blue loops, implying that diffusion is being inhibited. We argue that M13's HB is a somewhat pathological case - the dominant HB population occurs very near the "knee" in optical CMDs, and evolved stars exclusively appear redward of that peak, leading to the incorrect appearance of a continuation of the unevolved HB. M13 has a distinct group of HB stars previously identified with the second U jump, which may be examples of early hot flashers that ignite core helium fusion shortly after leaving the RGB. However, there is not convincing evidence that a large fraction of stars leave the RGB before helium flash. We revisited the helium-sensitive R ratio, and find that M13's ratio is in agreement with theoretical values for primordial helium abundance Y_P = 0.245 and inconsistent with a helium enhancement DY = 0.04. The brightness of the HB (both in comparison to the end of the canonical HB and to the tip of the RGB) also appears to rule out the idea that the envelopes of the reddest HB stars have been significantly enriched in helium. The absolute colors of the turnoffs of M3 and M13 may potentially be used to look for differences in their mean helium abundances.(ABRIDGED)