Towards a high precision calculation for the pion-nucleus scattering lengths

TL;DR

This paper develops a high-precision theoretical framework for calculating pion-nucleus scattering lengths, focusing on few-nucleon contributions and power counting, with implications for extracting fundamental scattering parameters.

Contribution

It introduces a controlled calculation method for pion-nucleus scattering lengths, analyzing multi-nucleon effects and testing power counting schemes like Weinberg's in this context.

Findings

Achieves a few percent accuracy for isoscalar nuclei scattering lengths.

Finds a suppression factor of 5 in N- vs. (N+1)-nucleon operator contributions.

Demonstrates limitations of heavy pion effective field theory for certain calculations.

Abstract

We calculate the leading isospin conserving few-nucleon contributions to pion scattering on $^2$H, $^3$He, and $^4$He. We demonstrate that the strong contributions to the pion-nucleus scattering lengths can be controlled theoretically to an accuracy of a few percent for isoscalar nuclei and of 10% for isovector nuclei. In particular, we find the $\pi$-$^3$He scattering length to be $(62 \pm 4\pm 7)\times 10^{-3} m_{\pi}^{-1}$ where the uncertainties are due to ambiguities in the $\pi$-N scattering lengths and few-nucleon effects, respectively. To establish this accuracy we need to identify a suitable power counting for pion-nucleus scattering. For this purpose we study the dependence of the two-nucleon contributions to the scattering length on the binding energy of $^2$H. Furthermore, we investigate the relative size of the leading two-, three-, and four-nucleon contributions. For the numerical evaluation of the pertinent integrals, aMonte Carlo method suitable for momentum space is devised. Our results show that in general the power counting suggested by Weinberg is capable to properly predict the relative importance of $N$-nucleon operators, however, it fails to capture the relative strength of $N$- and $(N+1)$-nucleon operators, where we find a suppression by a factor of 5 compared to the predicted factor of 50. The relevance for the extraction of the isoscalar $\pi$-N scattering length from pionic $^2$H and $^4$He is discussed. As a side result, we show that beyond the calculation of the $\pi$-$^2$H scattering length is already beyond the range of applicability of heavy pion effective field theory.