No evidence for dust extinction in GRB 050904 at z ~ 6.3

TL;DR

This study reanalyzed the afterglow of GRB 050904 at z ~ 6.3 and found no evidence of dust extinction, challenging previous claims of unusual dust in its host galaxy based on spectral data.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive reanalysis of multi-epoch data, demonstrating that earlier evidence for dust extinction in the high-redshift GRB host was not statistically significant.

Findings

No significant dust extinction detected in the afterglow SED.

The Z-band suppression previously reported is statistically insignificant.

The data do not support the presence of SN-origin dust in the host galaxy.

Abstract

Context: GRB afterglows are excellent probes of gas and dust in star-forming galaxies at all epochs. It has been posited that dust in the early Universe must be different from dust at lower z. To date two reports directly support this contention, one of which is based on the spectral shape of GRB 050904 at z = 6.295. Aims: We reinvestigate the afterglow to understand dust at high z. We address the claimed evidence for unusual (SN-origin) dust in its host galaxy by simultaneously examining the X-ray and optical/NIR spectrophotometric data. Methods: We derive the intrinsic SED of the afterglow at 0.47, 1.25 and 3.4 days, by re-reducing the Swift X-ray data, the 1.25 days FORS2 z-Gunn photometric data, the spectroscopic and z'-band photometric data at ~3 days from the Subaru telescope, as well as the critical UKIRT Z-band photometry at 0.47 days, upon which the claim of dust detection largely relies. Results: We find no evidence of dust extinction in the SED. We compute flux densities at lambda_rest = 1250 AA directly from the observed counts at all epochs. In the earliest epoch, 0.47 days, the Z-band suppression is found to be smaller (0.3 +- 0.2 mag) than previously reported and statistically insignificant (<1.5 sigma). Furthermore we find that the photometry of this band is unstable and difficult to calibrate. Conclusions: From the afterglow SED we demonstrate that there is no evidence for dust extinction -- the SED at all times can be reproduced without dust, and at 1.25 days in particular, significant extinction can be excluded, with A(3000 AA) < 0.27 mag at 95% confidence using the SN-type extinction curve. We conclude that there is no evidence of any extinction in the afterglow of GRB 050904 and that the presence of SN-origin dust in the host of GRB 050904 must be viewed skeptically. [abridged]