The Complexity of Flood Filling Games

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the computational complexity of Flood-It, proving NP-hardness for certain variants, providing approximation algorithms, and studying the number of moves needed in worst-case and random scenarios.

Contribution

It establishes NP-hardness results for Flood-It with multiple colors, offers approximation algorithms, and analyzes move complexity in worst-case and probabilistic settings.

Findings

NP-hard for c>=3 colors, even with free flooding

Polynomial time solvable for c=2 and height 2 boards

Number of moves grows as Theta(n*c^0.5) in worst case

Abstract

We study the complexity of the popular one player combinatorial game known as Flood-It. In this game the player is given an n by n board of tiles where each tile is allocated one of c colours. The goal is to make the colours of all tiles equal via the shortest possible sequence of flooding operations. In the standard version, a flooding operation consists of the player choosing a colour k, which then changes the colour of all the tiles in the monochromatic region connected to the top left tile to k. After this operation has been performed, neighbouring regions which are already of the chosen colour k will then also become connected, thereby extending the monochromatic region of the board. We show that finding the minimum number of flooding operations is NP-hard for c>=3 and that this even holds when the player can perform flooding operations from any position on the board. However, we show that this "free" variant is in P for c=2. We also prove that for an unbounded number of colours, Flood-It remains NP-hard for boards of height at least 3, but is in P for boards of height 2. Next we show how a c-1 approximation and a randomised 2c/3 approximation algorithm can be derived, and that no polynomial time constant factor, independent of c, approximation algorithm exists unless P=NP. We then investigate how many moves are required for the "most demanding" n by n boards (those requiring the most moves) and show that the number grows as fast as Theta(n*c^0.5). Finally, we consider boards where the colours of the tiles are chosen at random and show that for c>=2, the number of moves required to flood the whole board is Omega(n) with high probability.