CO J=6--5 in Arp 220: strong effects of dust on high-J CO lines

TL;DR

This study reveals that dust optical depth significantly suppresses high-J CO line emission in Arp 220, affecting interpretations of molecular gas conditions in ULIRGs and highlighting the importance of dust effects in high-frequency line diagnostics.

Contribution

It demonstrates that dust optical depth can obscure high-J CO lines in ULIRGs, challenging previous assumptions about molecular gas excitation based solely on line ratios.

Findings

High-J CO lines are faint due to dust absorption.

Dust optical depth explains the CII line deficiency.

Implications for high-frequency line diagnostics in ULIRGs.

Abstract

We report new single dish CO J=6--5 line observations for the archetypal Ultra Luminous Infrared Galaxy (ULIRG) Arp 220 with the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope atop Mauna Kea in Hawaii. The J=6--5 line is found to be faint, with brightness temperature ratios (6--5)/(1--0), (6--5)/(3--2) of R_{65/10} = 0.080+/-0.017 and R_{65/32} = 0.082+/-0.019, suggesting very low excitation conditions that cannot be reconciled with the warm and very dense molecular gas present in one of the most extreme starbursts in the local Universe. We find that an optically thick dust continuum, with tau(f>350 GHz)>=1 for the bulk of the warm dust and gas in Arp 220, submerges this line to an almost black body curve, reducing its flux, and {\it affecting its CO Spectral Line Energy Distribution (SLED) at high frequencies}. This also resolves the CII line deficiency in this object, first observed by {\it ISO}: the near absence of that line is a dust optical depth effect, not a dense Photodissociation Region (PDR) phenomenon. Finally we briefly comment on the possibility of such extreme ISM states in other ULIRGs in the distant Universe, and its consequences for the diagnostic utility of high frequency molecular and atomic ISM lines in such systems. In the case of Arp 220 we anticipate that the now spaceborne Herschel Space Observatory will find faint high-J CO lines at f>=690 GHz that would appear as sub-thermally excited with respect to the low-J ones as a result of the effects of dust absorption.