Revised Results for Non-thermal Recombination Flare Hard X-Ray Emission

TL;DR

This paper corrects previous analyses of non-thermal recombination's role in solar flare hard X-ray emissions, showing it is not dominant but still significant for spectral modeling and electron spectrum inference.

Contribution

It identifies and corrects errors in prior work, demonstrating that non-thermal recombination does not dominate over bremsstrahlung in hot flare plasmas, refining the understanding of HXR emission sources.

Findings

NTR does not dominate over NTB in hot flare plasmas.

Corrected calculations show NTR can be comparable to NTB in some cases.

NTR spectral edges impact electron spectrum inversion.

Abstract

Brown and Mallik (BM) recently showed that, for hot sources, recombination of non-thermal electrons (NTR) onto highly ionised heavy ions is not negligible compared to non-thermal bremsstrahlung (NTB) as a source of flare hard X-rays (HXRs) and so should be included in modelling non-thermal HXR flare emission. In view of major discrepancies between BM results for the THERMAL continua and those of the Chianti code and of RHESSI solar data, we critically re-examine and correct the BM analysis and modify the conclusions concerning the importance of NTR. Although the analytic Kramers expression used by BM is correct for the purely hydrogenic recombination cross section, the heuristic expressions used by BM to extend the Kramers expression beyond the `bare nucleus' case to which it applies had serious errors. BM results have therefore been recalculated using corrected expressions, which have been validated against the results of detailed calculations. At T ~ 10-30 MK the dominant ions are Fe 22+, 23+, 24+ for which BM erroneously overestimated NTR emission by around an order of magnitude. Contrary to the BM claim, NTR in hot flare plasmas does NOT dominate over NTB, although in some cases it can be comparable and so still very important in inversions of photon spectra to derive electron spectra, especially as NTR includes sharp edge features. The BM claim of dominance of NTR over NTB in deka-keV emission is incorrect due to a serious error in their analysis. However, the NTR contribution can still be large enough to demand inclusion in spectral fitting, the spectral edges having potentially serious effects on inversion of HXR spectra to infer fast electron spectra.