An Evaluation of the Excitation Class Parameter for the Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae

TL;DR

This paper compares existing methods for estimating the excitation class of planetary nebulae's central stars, introduces a new combined method, and evaluates their effectiveness against temperature measurements, highlighting the need for clearer terminology.

Contribution

It introduces a new excitation class estimation method (Exrho) that improves agreement with stellar temperatures compared to previous methods.

Findings

Existing methods show significant discrepancies in estimating excitation class.

The new Exrho method offers better correlation with Zanstra temperatures.

Clarification of the term 'excitation class' is necessary due to different input parameters.

Abstract

The three main methods currently in use for estimating the excitation class of planetary nebulae (PNe) central stars are compared and evaluated using 586 newly discovered and previously known PNe in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC). In order to achieve this we ran a series of evaluation tests using line ratios derived from de-reddened, flux calibrated spectra. Pronounced differences between the methods are exposed. Diagrams were created by comparing excitation classes with H-beta line fluxes. The best methods are then compared to published temperatures using the Zanstra method and assessed for their ability to reflect central star effective temperatures and evolution. As a result we call for a clarification of the term `excitation class' according to the different input parameters used. The first method, which we refer to as Exneb relies purely on the ratios of certain key emission lines. The second method, which we refer to as Ex* includes modeling to create a continuous variable and, for optically thick PNe in the Magellanic Clouds, is designed to relate more closely to intrinsic stellar parameters. The third method, we refer to as Ex [OIII]/H-beta since the [OIII]/H-beta ratio is used in isolation to other temperature diagnostics. Each of these methods is shown to have serious drawbacks when used as an indicator for central star temperature. Finally, we suggest a new method (Exrho) for estimating excitation class incorporating both the [OIII]/H-beta and the HeII4686 /H-beta ratios. Although any attempt to provide accurate central star temperatures using the excitation class derived from nebula lines will always be limited, we show that this new method provides a substantial improvement over previous methods with better agreement to temperatures derived through the Zanstra method.